Susan Murphy-Milano...

Moving Out Moving On" is a very practical resource to safety and sanity for all of our lives. The information you receive will take you from the State of Being Controlled to the State of Being in Control.

2006/5/26

Reforming A Murderer Is Not Possible

Tags:
@ 05:31 AM (46 months, 12 days ago)

A few weeks ago the Chicago Sun Times revisited a murder story that in 1976 stunned all who lived in Chicago.  A young woman, around the same age as me at the time, all of 17 years old,  arrested for shooting and butchering her entire family.

Now thirty years later this "reformed woman" is up for parole.  And there are individuals who believe she has been reformed, turned her life around and deserves to be released. Pleeze!!!

Thirty years after she and her lover shot and butchered her family, Patty Columbo spoke with Carol Marin of the Sun-Times in an exclusive interview from prison.

On May 7, 1976 police found the bodies of Frank, Mary and Michael Columbo in their Elk Grove Village home. After just 10 days, police charged 19-year-old Patty Columbo with the murders. Two months later, her 37-year-old lover, Frank DeLuca, was also charged.

The video

Part 1 | Part 2
Extra: Parole chances
Extra: Columbo interview
Extra: Arresting detective
Extra: Interview outtakes
The photos

The crime
The evidence

 Here is just one of the many letters advocating for her release.....

Patricia Columbo and those supporting her plea for parole attribute her rehabilitation to having successfully obtained a college degree and participated in other programs which, as she correctly observed, have virtually disappeared in today's correction system.

Some may wonder why we should care to spend a nickel on rehabilitating the incarcerated. But there are sound reasons for Illinois to seriously consider restoring meaningful programs and educational opportunities for its entire prison population.

First, rehabilitation of all prisoners makes prisons safer for the people who work there. Second, 95 percent of all those serving time leave prison at some point. Investing in their rehabilitation improves public safety. Third, long-termers and lifers should not be excluded from rehabilitative programming because the way they serve their time affects other prisoners who will be leaving.

The Sun-Times series raises a second important issue. Whatever one thinks of the merits of Columbo's case, parole, which is not available to inmates sentenced today, should be reintroduced in Illinois. Over time, some of the worst offenders end up turning their lives around in prison, are no longer threats to public safety, and have a lot to offer to the outside world. The parole process provides a mechanism to decide whether continued incarceration is necessary or desirable for an individual inmate.

There are men and women in prison whom none of us would want to see released. But the system should not be designed to treat every prisoner as if they were the worst of the worst or, for that matter, the best of the best. We should have a system that can release prisoners who have served substantial time, based on equity, fairness and the individual.

Shaena Fazal, director,
Long-Term Prisoner Policy Project,
John Howard Association of Illinois